Home | Features | Veterans | Survivor Guilt Related to PTSD

Survivor Guilt Related to PTSD

Font size: Decrease font Enlarge font

There are all kinds of trauma for veterans.... even for those who didn't serve in a combat zone

With the latest information in the news stating that more veterans have committed suicide than have died in Afghanistan this year, it raises some interesting questions/thoughts.  According to the June 8, 2012, article on page A4 of The Spokesman-Review, “154 suicides for active-duty troops in the first 155 days of the year far outdistance the U.S. forces killed in action in Afghanistan—by about 50 percent more—according to Pentagon statistics obtained by the Associated Press.” And further in the article, “Army data suggest soldiers with multiple combat tours are at greater risk of committing suicide, although a substantial proportion of Army suicides are committed by soldiers who never deployed.”

I suggest that perhaps the military needs to look at the effect that Survivor Guilt for non-deployed members of the military has on them, as it relates to this apparent upswing in suicides in the military. For instance, hypothetically, a male or female member of the military trains with the same personnel through Basic Training and then on through Advanced Individual Training. When it comes time for deployment to a “combat zone,” one or more of the group is not sent into a “combat zone,” and as a matter of fact, is not deployed outside of the U.S. (CONUS). The individual(s) then receives reports from the “combat zone” that a number of his/her close friends/comrades have been killed and/or have lost limbs, while he/she is safely out of harm’s way. Sure, he/she could have been deployed, but they weren’t. Now, after hearing the aforementioned report, he/she begins to feel guilty; guilty that they not only survived, but didn’t even have to go anywhere near a war zone. This “Survivor Guilt” intensifies to the point where the non combat veteran believes that if he/she had been with their buddies, perhaps they could have prevented some or all of the deaths of their friends.

As time goes by, this feeling of, ‘If only I’d been there with them, maybe this wouldn’t have happened to them,” intensifies and manifests itself into something like an obsession. Eventually the veteran suffers from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder as related to “Survivor Guilt,” even though they weren’t physically there with their buddies in combat.

Question to be pondered:  What responsibility does the Veterans Administration have towards these non combat, non deployed veterans as relates to psychiatric care and counseling due to their “Survivor Guilt?”

I submit that the above is an area that the VA and military need to look into immediately to see how it does or doesn’t relate to these increased suicide rates, especially in non deployed veterans.

Subscribe to comments feed Comments (4 posted)

DC 06/30/2013 01:47:06
I became severely injured in the line of duty, not combat, so, I was going through * Physical Disability Evaluation Board when my unit and husband deployed without me. We lost * few pilots and I do suffer from suvivors guilt. I don't even consider myself * "real" veteran because I didn't deploy. If you look up suvivors guilt, it also includes people who didn't lose their job during * mass lay off, but feel guilty that their friends were. I do have PTSD but I never claimed it, nor will I ever. Yeah, there are those people that hide out when it comes time to deploy, but for some, it is beyond their control. I fell off * helicopter and I had my whole career and livelihood ripped away from me. I also had * surgery where an Army doctor screwed up and later found out he was kicked out of the Army 2 weeks after my surgery and Darnell Army Hospital "lost" all surgical notes, pictures, and records of that surgery. All they had were my Surgery release papers and after care instructions.
Cdarienzo 04/15/2013 15:34:50
Those other two are correct. But I was 11b for 10 years. Never got to use it. I still hold onto some kind of guilt that I didnt deploy with my guys. Its been years and I cant let it down. Its not PTSD in any way but the depression and guilt is staggering.

Dont know what you'd call it but its staggering,
tom 08/08/2012 02:16:13
wrong meaning for survivor guilt. Survivor guilt is when you are serving beside your friend in real combat and your friend does not survive and you do and usually kicks in when you are leaving to come back to the states. You wonder how the bullet missed you, but hit him. There is no such thing as survivor guilt for people who did not deploy or for support people in * war zone. This is just like the phony ptsd for support people who were never in combat. Ptsd comes from being in real combat day in and day out, not from just being in an area of danger.
08/31/2012 00:30:21

Huge +1 to your post. Almost all the guys I know that claimed PTSD are pogues or guys that never saw combat. Makes it * lot harder on those of us who actually did and experience problems stemming from it.
total: 3 | displaying: 1 - 3

Post your comment

  • Bold
  • Italic
  • Underline
  • Quote

Please enter the code you see in the image:

  • Email to a friend Email to a friend
  • Print version Print version
  • Plain text Plain text

Author info

Michael Harmelin

Tagged as:

veterans, PTSD, survivor guilt

Rate this article